| Platinum | Pearl Tavern |
| Gold | Red Crab Boil |
| Silver | Red Lobster |
| Bronze | Krab Kingz |
| Top Pick | Calaveras |
| Top Pick | Jumpin Catfish Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Jumpin' Catfish Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Marina 27 Steak & Seafood |
| Top Pick | Smoke Brewing Company |
| Top Pick | Third Street Social |