| Platinum | Martin City Pizza and Tap Room |
| Gold | Long-Bell Pizza Co |
| Silver | Minsky's Pizza |
| Bronze | Main Slice |
| Top Pick | Casey's General Store |
| Top Pick | Fun House Pizza |
| Top Pick | Konrad's Kitchen and Tap House |
| Top Pick | Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pizza Shoppe |
| Top Pick | Pizza Street |
